They found that among epilepsy patients with psychosis, those who were female, had temporal lobe involvement, and were using levetiracetam (multiple brands) were substantially more likely to have AED-induced psychotic disorder (AIPD) than other psychotic disorders. In contrast, the use of carbamazepine (multiple brands) was associated with a markedly reduced risk for AIPD.
Patrick Kwan, MD, PhD, the University of Melbourne, the Royal Melbourne Hospital, Victoria, Australia, toldMedscape Medical News that the “central message” of the study is that, with regard to cases of psychotic disorders among epilepsy patients, “1 in 7 could potentially be attributed to antiepileptic drugs.”
He added, “With cessation of the culprit drug, the outcome in these patients was better than in those with psychotic symptoms due to other causes.”
Dr Kwan explained that although prescribing practices need not be reexamined in the light of the findings, “when a clinician is faced with an epilepsy patient presenting with psychotic symptoms, they could use the factors identified in our study to help determine whether the symptoms are related to the patient’s antiepileptic medications or other causes.
“This differentiation obviously is important for choosing appropriate treatment path,” he said.
The research was published online August 8 by the journal Brain.
Approached for comment, Daniel S. Weisholtz, MD, Department of Neurology, Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, said that the study is “a nice contribution to the literature” and “draws attention to the importance of considering the possible contribution of levetiracetam and other AEDs when a patient with epilepsy develops psychosis.”
He noted that one of the strengths of the study is that the investigators used “rigorous classification scheme definitions that is in keeping with a modern understanding of the different types of psychosis in epilepsy.” He added: “When encountering an epilepsy patient manifesting symptoms of psychosis, it is important to consider the many different potential causes, only one of which is AIPD.”
However, Dr Weisholtz told Medscape Medical Newsthat the findings are “preliminary and should be interpreted with caution.”
He pointed out that because the researchers only compared AIPD patients with epilepsy patients who were manifesting psychosis for other reasons, it is “not really legitimate to say, for example, that, based on this study, levetiracetam increases the risk of psychosis overall.” He also noted that the researchers did not quantify the time of onset of psychotic symptoms, which would help to identify them as being due to an AED.
He that this study nevertheless suggests that when a patient with epilepsy develops psychosis, use of levetiracetam, female sex, and an epileptogenic lesion involving the temporal lobe may increase the probability that the psychosis is AED induced.
“I think, from looking at this study, if I had a psychotic patient who was on levetiracetam…I would be more inclined, perhaps, to try to get them off levetiracetam and onto something else, maybe carbamazepine, because it seems to be potentially more protective,” Dr Weisholtz added.
To examine the clinical spectrum of AIPD, the researchers reviewed the records of 2630 inpatients and outpatients with epilepsy who were seen at the Royal Melbourne Hospital between 1993 and 2015, of whom 98 (3.7%) were found to have psychotic disorders. Among these 98 patients, the median age at the time of onset of epilepsy was 18.5 years; the median age at the time of onset of psychosis was 34.5 years.
The psychosis was classified as being an AIPD in 14 of 98 (14.3%) patients; it was deemed unrelated to AED therapy in the remaining 84 of 98 (85.7%) patients. The latter consisted of 33 patients with interictal psychosis of epilepsy, 25 with postictal psychosis, 19 with comorbid schizophrenia/schizophreniform disorder, and seven with psychotic disorder induced by other medications.
Compared with non-AIPD patients, those with AIPD were more likely to be female (76.9% vs 41.7%; P < .05). They were also more likely to have structural/metabolic epilepsy (84.6% vs 56.0%; P < .05) and temporal lobe involvement (69.2% vs 38.1%; P < .05).
In terms of psychiatric manifestations, AIPD patients were more likely than non-AIPD patients to have disorganized behaviors and thinking (100% vs 72.6% and 76.9% vs 64.3%, respectively; P < .05 for both). The duration of psychotic episodes was 1 week in 42.9% of AIPD patients vs 22.6% of non-AIPD patients (P < .05).
The proportion of patients receiving continuous antipsychotic treatment was lower in the AIPD patients than in the non-AIPD patients (15.4% vs 66.7%; P < .01). No AIPD patients experienced a chronic course of psychosis, whereas 40.5% of those in the non-AIPD group did.
The study was supported by funding through an Australian and New Zealand Association of Neurologists Bayer Asia Pacific Region Neurology educational grant. Dr Kwan has received research grants from the National Health and Medical Research Council of Australia, the Australian Research Council, the US National Institutes of Health, the Hong Kong Research Grants Council, the Innovation and Technology Fund, the Health and Health Services Research Fund, and the Health and Medical Research Fund. He or his institution also received speaker or consultancy fees and/or research grants from Eisai, GlaxoSmithKline, Johnson & Johnson, Pfizer, and UCB Pharma.
Brain. Published online August 8, 2016